

I'd never heard of director Leo McCarey until I popped Criterion's new release of Make Way for Tomorrow (1937) into my player. I guess that's terrible isn't it? I mean I had obviously heard of some of his films, like Love Affair and it's remake An Affair To Remember (which I just rented), but I was ignorant of McCarey the director. I didn't know that at one time he was one of the most successful director's in Hollywood and I certainly didn't know that he possessed a completely unique improvisational style and was known for deftly switching back and forth between whip-smart comedy and tear-jerking human drama (genuinely tear-jerking). While I feel bad about not knowing of McClary's work, after watching Make Way for Tomorrow I feel like I'm discovering him at the right time--a little older, a little wiser, and now a husband and father. I don't think I would've been ready to appreciate him as a teenager or in my 20's.
I intended to just start Make Way for Tomorrow before heading to bed, finishing up the rest on another night. But the film reeled me in from the get-go and didn't give me any reasons to want to pause. By the time its magical, beautiful and devastating ending gave way to credits, I had drank the better part of a bottle of wine and lost an hour and half of sleep to the laughter and tears that the film will milk from all but the most stone-hearted viewers.
On the surface, Make Way for Tomorrow appears to be about generational conflict--and it is to a certain extent--but in scene after scene it reveals itself instead to be an uncommon and tragic love story. Not your typical love story mind you, where boy meets girl and fate conspires to keep them apart for two reels before inevitable reconciliation. This is a love story about a couple who spend 50 years together and then are split apart by circumstance to face the final years of their life apart.
The film begins with a wide shot of a pleasant little house set behind a white picket fence in an idyllic rural winter wonderland. It's the kind of shot you often see in old black and white movies where you can't tell if it's a real place or just a painting, but either way you want to climb inside the screen and live there. But this is the last we'll see of the house and the warm feelings it invokes. Ma and Pa Cooper have called their children home to deliver some bad news. With Pa retired, he hasn't been able to keep up the payments and the bank is taking the house. The couple have to be out by Tuesday. Once the news hits the air the children begin nervously playing a game of hot potato with their elderly parents, tossing around the idea of taking them in, yet nobody wanting to hold onto it for too long. George, the eldest child, takes the role of chief negotiator. He works the problem out loud, tending to talk over his parents as if their opinions on the matter are of no importance. This scene is imbued with a great deal of comedy, with the children exchanging barbed remarks that reveal a life-long familiarity with each others quirks. McCarey is playing an uncomfortable familial scenario for some laughs, disarming the inherent sadness of the circumstance in order to draw the viewer in. But despite humour, the film begins with the saying "honor thy mother and father" and McCarey proceeds to etch this creed into your heart by showing the opposite
When the dust has settled, it has been established that none of the children are able (or willing) to accommodate both their parents, so they will have to split up. Everyone kids themselves that this is a temporary arrangement. Pa with go to live with daughter Cora and her husband in an unnamed small town, while Ma will bunk in with George and his family in their apartment in New York City. Bark and Lucy Cooper have been married for 50 years and aside from his nightly visits to the barber shop to hang out with the boys, they have never been apart. But the couple is waging a silent battle with their own pride, and already feeling like burdens, they don't want to rock the boat by demanding another resolution. They go along with the plan, painfully saying goodbye.
The film then divides itself between each half of the couple, exploring the uncomfortable dynamics of their new living arrangements. First we follow Lucy, who is completely at odds with her uptown big-city surroundings. Her teenaged granddaughter is cavorting with a rotating cast of older men, while her son and daughter-in-law are hosting tuxedo bridge gatherings in their living room. This is a world and a pace of life that Lucy can't quite grasp and she sticks out like a sore thumb. When granddaughter Rhoda flippantly says "face facts, grandma" Lucy explains why she may seem a little out-of-touch, saying that at her age folks like to "pretend there aren't any facts to face". It's a crushing line that so simply puts the elderly experience into sharp relief against the inevitable. If the film were comprised of only moments like these, it would make for an absolutely joyless slog. But McCarey and screenwriter Vina Delmar wisely dial up the laughs before sucker-punching you in the gut with sadness.
In one of the most memorable sequences, Lucy is contrasted against the black tie guests that George and his wife Anita are entertaining. With her old rocking chair set in the middle of the room, it's incessant squeaking cuts through the silence of everyone working out their bridge hands. George and Anita are squirming in their seats, mortified by her presence. Then the phone rings, and it's Bark for his wife. Lucy shouts into the phone as old people often do, commanding the attention of the whole room who are forced to eavesdrop on her side of the conversation. With her back to the crowd, Lucy is framed as if she is performing on stage, with the black tie guests her audience. It is a funny comedy of manners, this old lady interrupting an uptown evening, but then the scene turns. The guests whose faces at first showed irritation begin to melt as Lucy exchanges loving sentiments with Bark. She misses him terribly and worries for his health with the winter weather so bitter. The faces of the guests fall and flash, showing sympathy and sweetness for Lucy, but then also shame at how that they had first received her. George and Anita are also riding this roller coaster of emotions, although more intensely than anyone. It deepens their characters, moving them away from caricatures of an ungrateful generation. It's an absolutely brilliant sequence and one of the most moving scenes I can think of in a film.
It's scenes like these where McCarey shows his gift for making empathy look effortless, but also essential to navigating a family and society at large. He also further distinguishes himself away from sentimental manipulation. This would be an easy situation to exploit for generational guilt. The children could be spoiled and the parents saintly, but McCarey avoids this trap. He rounds out the characters of the children and exposes the faults of the parents. Bark and Lucy are sweet people, but they are also very stubborn and not a little irritating. You can see how resorting to living with either of them again would be a bitter pill to swallow for their adult children who have lives and problems of their own. And the children are selfish and self-absorbed, but yet still able to recognize and name their conflicting feelings about their parents, making it hard to hate them for their actions (well, maybe you do hate Cora a little). They are not simply one-dimensional brats and this is not a situation to view from only one side.
Life without his Lucy is hitting Bark hard. He is sick with a persistent cold and his daughter Cora doesn't have the bedside manner of his kindly wife. His only friend is Max Reuben, the Jewish merchant whose shop Bark likes to visit. The two men have become friends and Max is very concerned for Bark's lonely heart. In another tear-jerker scene, Max reads to him a letter from Lucy because his glasses are broken. The actor that plays Max masterfully tells a story with his facial expressions, communicating the truth behind Lucy's words--she is just as lonely without him and her son George may or may not be softening her up to the idea of an old-folks home. This unspoken action beneath the surface of a scene is a common thread through Make Way for Tomorrow. When Bark leaves the shop, Max immediately calls for his wife, just to look into her eyes and tell her he loves her--he wants to seize the little moments that most of us let slip by, because his friend Bark cannot. Another wonderful, heart-tugging moment in a film filled with similar universal emotions, explored with both craft and heart.
[*My Mom tells me I spoil the ending here, so from here on out- SPOILER ALERT*]
Towards the end of the film, Bark and Lucy are permitted one final afternoon together in the city where they took their honeymoon 50 years ago. Cora has persuaded a young doctor to agree that Bark's condition will only improve if he moves to a warmer climate, so he's in New York to catch a train to California, to stay with their other daughter. Once again, Lucy cannot come with him. Both of them know that this is likely the last time they will see each other--they spend the afternoon and evening pretending that there aren't any facts to face. Like I said, this ending is magical, giving the elderly couple a last hurrah that is as sweet and romantic as anything Hollywood has ever done with two lovebirds.
They visit the hotel where they stayed on their honeymoon and get a little tipsy at the bar. They dance a waltz and laugh about old memories over dinner--ignoring the fact that their worried family is waiting for them to arrive at goodbye dinner they have prepared. Every stranger they meet is delighted to accommodate the couple, as if they preternaturally sense their impending separation. This is no accident as McCarey seems to be saying that it is sometimes easier for us to see the humanity and emotional needs of strangers over the very people we share our lives with. The hotel manager and the big-band leader and even the somewhat sleazy car salesman all treat Lucy and Bart infinitely better than we see their children do. One of the small tragedies of everyday life.
Like many classic Hollywood romances, Make Way for Tomorrow ends on a train platform with a painful goodbye. The couple is forced to consider the line of their 50 year love affair that has led them unexpectedly to the open doors of a train that will end it once and for all. IT IS FUCKING BRUTAL. On the Special Features, you learn that Orson Welles said of Make Way for Tomorrow, "it would make a stone cry".
Make Way for Tomorrow is a remarkable film, pretty much unlike anything I've ever seen. How many other movies can you name that deal so frankly with old age? Or with old age at all? Further, the film refuses to show growing old as some transition into a philosophical ease with one's own insignificance or lost vitality, like a fair trade for wisdom. Bark and Lucy's love is still significant and they have lost none of their vitality or thirst for life--and yet they still have to act as if their feelings no longer matter. It is a bitter, bitter pill that the film tells us the world will try to make us all swallow one day, one that will inevitably catch in our throats. Make Way for Tomorrow is a simple yet universally important story told with a lot of nuance. It's fantastic.